Apparently there's a
Top 5 YA Crushes thing going around? I wanted to do this, since I always like talking about myself, but I didn't actually read that much YA when I was in the proper age range. Mostly I read kids' books and Piers Anthony. And once I started reading more YA, I was too old to really crush on the characters; mostly I just think they're adorable and wee. So I present to you my
Top 5 Kids and YA Crushes, Sort Of, roughly in the order I encountered them:
1. Sam Thomas and Alan Gray (
The Baby-Sitters Club, Ann M. Martin)
Did I mention that I am bending the rules further by listing 5 canons instead of 5 characters? Whoops. I have always had a weakness for comic relief boys, and thus found Sam and Alan both totally adorable as a kid. Sam, fair enough; Alan, I have discovered upon rereading as an adult, I probably was not supposed to like as much as I did, but oh well. They like to annoy the girls they like but are inherently decent! I
love that! And apparently Alan gets more well-rounded in
Friends Forever, which pleases me, even if I can't picture him with Claudia instead of Kristy.
Honorable mentions go to Bart Taylor, who I liked as a kid because I automatically liked Kristy's love interest, but who I find kind of lackluster as an adult, and Charlie Thomas, who I didn't care about as a kid, but whose good-natured responsibleness has won me over as an adult.
2. Edmund Pevensie and Eustace Scrubb (
The Chronicles of Narnia, C.S. Lewis)
I cannot piiiiiiick. Both Edmund and Eustace are flawed characters when we meet them, in sharp contrast to the shining benevolence of the other kids around them, and both go through hellish experiences and come out the other side wiser, but still very much themselves. I love that Eustace isn't perfect after he turns back into a boy - he can still be peevish, all the way through the end of the series - but he's
trying. And I love that Edmund, who was always the brains of the family, grows up to be a wise, thoughtful man whose most important characteristic is his
fairness. The prickly ones are so much more interesting than the perfect ones.
3. Pickles Johnson (
School Daze, Jerry Spinelli)
I swear, someday I will make my post about these books. Pickles is just one of those utterly captivating people who comes up with madcap schemes and you don't think to ask why you're going along with it until you're halfway through. He's a brilliant inventor in such a charming
kid way, and utterly, hilariously confident in even his more ridiculous schemes. He's deeply loyal to his friends, utterly fearless, and sweetly, boyishly
nice, and every time I read a scene about another one of his strangely enchanting quirks the nine-year-old in me swoons.
He plays taps when the school's hamster dies. I LOVE HIM.
4. Dandin (
Mariel of Redwall and
The Bellmaker, Brian Jacques)
I have a
thing for thieves, and by all right Gonff, Prince of Mousethieves, should be on this list, but I'm trying to stick to kids and teens on my kids and teens list, and I always got the impression that Gonff, immature as he is, is in his early 20s (or whatever mouse years correspond to that). But Dandin, Gonff's great-grandson, has inherited a lot of his thiefish sass, mitigated by a more straight-forward hero nature (actually a lot of the flute-playing, nimble daredevil thiefishness is gone by
The Bellmaker, which is kind of a bummer), and the blended archetypes work really well. I love how friendly and clever and loyal he is, and that he never tries to steal Mariel's spotlight, and that all he wants is to go on adventures with his best friend (and vaguely-suggested love interest OH I HOPE I HOPE I HOPE). Mariel is the reason that
Mariel of Redwall is my favorite Redwall book, but Dandin certainly helps!
5. Marco (
Animorphs, K.A. Applegate)
I hope you didn't miss the multiple mentions of how I like the funny ones. I'm a lot more cheerful than Marco (or any Animorphs character, thank God), but his life philosophy has matched mine as well as any fictional character I've ever encountered: you've got to laugh, because otherwise you'll cry. I love how he just wants to keep everyone sane with tomfoolery, and that he never wants anyone to feel sorry for him, and that he's keenly, cuttingly smart, because it takes brains to be funny. I love his insecurities and how he wants to take care of his dad, and I love that he is bad at driving a truck when he's a gorilla, and I love that he can apparently speak a tribal dialect of Portugese for no reason. I was the only one I knew who liked Marco instead of Tobias as a tween, but I stuck with it then, and I'm sticking with it now.
Honorable mentions:
George Cooper (
The Song of the Lioness Quartet, Tamora Pierce): I'm not sure if George counts, because he's a grown-up (okay, he's 17 when we meet him, but Alanna's 10 so that's like ancient to her), but he is one of my all-time literary crushes. So snarky! So devoted! So badass! ILU GEORGE.
Sam Moon (
Fearless, Francine Pascal): Sam is the only YA character I read when I was a teenager, and I thought he was SUPER dreamy when I was 16, but in retrospect he's kind of a spineless wonder and those books are ridiculous. Oh well!